who had the better career

Eli the goat !!!!

Brady

Eli beat Brady twice.

@smellybunty

 Brady is not on the list and Brady lost twice to Eli 

Brady has 7 to 2 and played at a much higher level and stats. If you think Eli is better you need mental help.

@smellybunty

 this thread is not a Brady and Eli comparison  , 

Peyton much better than Eli though I don't care for him.

This is a dumb thread. Anyone who thinks Eli is better is crazy.

@smellybunty

 explain , ELi is in the same top 10 categories as his brother , has a better playoff and sb record , played in a non climate controlled envoirment ,

@smellybunty

 Peyton played 3 more season with out that he ends with 1 Superbowl in 18 years  

Both have 2 SB and Eli stats are nowhere near as good.

@smellybunty

 wait what those eli comebacks was better than Peyton poor performance's Peyton had more Interceptions that TDs in the superbowls and we all know who deserved that last MVP VOnMiller

I am really starting to think you didn't watch football before last week. Eli Manning was mediocre. Not even a discussion. The guy had 366 TD's to go along with 244 Int's. Yup he's greatness personified.

@AJ86

 Peyton Manning threw 500 TDs and 251 interceptions  what your point ?

@AJ86

 you do know peyton is in the top 5 ints right ? you do know he has more ints than TDs in the Superbowls right ?

@AJ86

 Compare there stats there is maybe a 10-14% difference , Eli wins the Superbowl that the major defense regular season is preseason for Playoff teams , 

Not sure I follow. That defines his career? Didn't he go to 4 superbowls?

Shocked that Eli has 3 votes lol

@smellybunty

Again - Brady the is not a choice - He should have lost to the Raiders from Hus fumble and his kicker won 2 other SB - Had the most protection ever . 

@smellybunty

 within 10% of all stats 

@smellybunty

 one is undefeated 

@mjm1012

 should have more had a better career 

@smellybunty

 The op is a fan boy, nothing more and nothing less. So, of course, he is going to pick Eli

@VicVega91

stop jacking off Peyton and you wont be blinded with the internal dna of the big bro

Were you trying to make a dick and balls with the graph? You picked 2 awful choices and put the obvious one in the middle.

Agreed... And It's apparent "Wewinandone"  doesn't like Peyton , either.  

I think that's the real issue.